Plug-in hybrids: Is Europe heading for a new dieselgate?

In Europe, plug-in hybrid vehicle (PHEV) sales are soaring, with half a million expected to be sold this year alone. To comply with the 2020/21 EU car CO2 standard, which went into effect in January 2020, automakers must sell low-emission vehicles. But, in the real world, are these cars as low-emission as they appear in carmaker test labs? Or are PHEVs high-emission vehicles sold by automakers as a compliance ploy to meet CO2 targets?

Reported by Transport & Environment

Transport & Environment commissioned Emissions Analytics to test three of the most popular PHEVs sold in 2019: a BMW X5 (the longest EV range PHEV available), a Volvo XC60, and a Mitsubishi Outlander. This report discusses the test results and what they mean for this technology’s CO2 credentials.

Many PHEVs on the market today boast extremely low CO2 emissions – one-third or less of an equivalent conventional combustion engined vehicle. However, even when tested on the mildest of the tests and starting with a fully charged battery, none of the PHEVs tested achieve such low figures in the real world. The BMW X5, the best performer of the three PHEVs tested by T&E, exceeded official CO2 values by 28%, emitting 41g/km. The XC60 and Outlander emitted 115g/km and 86g/km, respectively, on the same mild test, representing a 62%- 89% difference from official WLTP values.

CO2 emissions of the XC60 and Outlander surged up to 184g/km and 164g/km, respectively, in tests where the car started with an empty battery (i.e. the internal combustion engine was powering the car), or nearly 3-4 times higher than official values. The X5’s CO2 emissions increased even more, reaching 254g/km, or eight times the official value.

Source: Plug-in hybrids Is Europe heading for a new dieselgate | Transport & Environment
Download Report
Reported by Transport & Environment

Related Partner Reports

September 18th update

Why affordable electric cars in 2025 are feasible

This report assesses the possibility of making €25,000 battery electric vehicles (BEVs) accessible in Europe by 2025. It analyzes factors affecting car prices, automaker strategies, and market dynamics. The report explores automaker profits, the rise of SUVs, and the discontinuation of smaller car models. It also examines the economic viability of small BEVs and their potential to boost electric...
Reported by Transport & Environment
August 14th update

Leasing is lagging: An analysis of BEV uptake in France

This report investigates France’s car leasing sector, emphasizing major players, profitability, and impact on decarbonization and electromobility. It highlights record profits, mergers, and the industry's role in promoting sustainable transportation.
Reported by Transport & Environment
August 7th update

Battery metals demand from electrifying passenger transport

The report examines the demand for battery raw materials to electrify European passenger transport under different scenarios. It highlights the significance of smaller batteries, innovative technologies, and policy measures to reduce demand responsibly and sustainably.
Reported by
July 10th update

Addendum: Addressing the heavy-duty climate problem

This report assesses the European Commission's proposal on CO2 standards for heavy-duty vehicles (HDVs) and compares it to more ambitious targets suggested by T&E. It analyzes the proposal's impact on emissions, energy consumption, and the EU's carbon budget, highlighting its shortcomings. The report recommends stronger CO2 targets for HDVs based on industry commitments for zero-emission sales by 2030.
Reported by Transport & Environment
June 28th update

Critical Raw Materials Act position paper

This report analyzes the European Union's CRM Act proposal for securing critical metals in the renewable energy transition. It discusses China's dominance in metal refining and the impact of the US Inflation Reduction Act. The report emphasizes the need for a balanced approach, stronger requirements for strategic projects and environmental reporting, and alignment with European values and community involvement....
Reported by Transport & Environment
June 26th update

State of the Industry Report 2023

This report provides an in-depth analysis of Plug&Charge, an industry-wide innovation revolutionizing EV charging. It covers the development, implementation, and adoption of Plug&Charge technology, along with key trends and business perspectives within the eMobility industry. The report aims to help readers gain a comprehensive understanding of the industry developments and make strategic decisions on implementing this future technology.
Reported by Hubject

Get started Free of Charge

EV Reports Database